Not really sure, I think they are awesome as well.. I think that it was enevitible they would have broken up no matter what anyone else said.

Obviously it is not up to the fans when it comes to band break-ups. GNR was a good rock band, but they could have been better with good band chemistry. Also, the stay at the top is not always a long one, so maybe something new was not a bad thing for any of them. I like root beer and vanilla ice cream, but not always together.